
Q: We’re building a new home and plan to sell our current home this December. We’ve lived here for 13 years, and our deck (now 10 years old) is showing signs of wear. We received a quote to rebuild it for $15,000. Our home is in a highly desirable neighborhood with a woods-facing lot, a built-in fire pit, and a playset. Is it worth spending the money to replace the deck, or should we sell as-is?
This is a great—and very common—question for homeowners preparing to sell.
The short answer? It depends.
Ask Yourself These Key Questions:
- Is the deck a safety hazard?
If the deck is structurally unsound or visibly dangerous, repairing it might be necessary. Buyers—and their inspectors—will flag safety issues. If it’s just worn, aged, or purely cosmetic, you likely have more flexibility. - How competitive is your market?
In high-demand neighborhoods where homes sell quickly regardless of condition, buyers may be more forgiving. If location is the biggest draw, they may be willing to overlook an outdated deck. - Are buyers expecting move-in ready homes?
In some areas, buyers want a finished product. In others, especially with limited inventory, buyers expect to make some upgrades themselves. - Is the deck a unique feature?
If the deck is custom-built with special design elements or integrated outdoor living features, updating it might hold more value. But if it’s a standard rectangle, buyers might prefer the chance to reimagine the space themselves—especially if they plan to replace it with composite or change the footprint. - What condition is the rest of the house in?
If everything else in your home is updated and turn-key, a tired deck might stand out more. But if there are a few areas that need a little love, the deck becomes just one of many future projects the buyer may accept.
From a Recent Buyer’s Perspective:
Some buyers want to put their own stamp on a home. Replacing a deck with the layout and materials they prefer can be more appealing than inheriting a brand-new wood deck that they feel obligated to maintain or eventually replace.
In short, unless your agent believes the deck is a major deterrent to a sale—or it poses a safety concern—you may be better off pricing the home accordingly and letting the next owners decide what to do with it.
When in doubt, talk to your real estate agent. They’ll understand local buyer expectations and market trends—and they’ll help you balance what to repair vs. what to leave as-is. Sometimes, the best investment before selling isn’t in rebuilding, but in strategic staging and pricing.
If you’re considering a move or investment and require a trusted Real Estate Broker, we’re here to assist you. Contact us via email at TEAM@McDanielCallahan.com, complete the form below, or give us a call at 925-838-4300. We are ready to provide expert guidance and support for all your real estate needs. Terry McDaniel DRE License #00941526





